Work / Chitragupt / Wiki / Decisions
2026-10-23-nav-is-plan-dependent-six-or-seven
Decisioncanonicalverified 2026-10-23
DECISION.2026-10-23.NAV-IS-PLAN-DEPENDENT-SIX-OR-SEVENTop nav has six or seven items; the four pillars stay
Decision
The product still has four pillars: Inbox, Tax, Expense, Portfolio. The personal nav lists Dashboard, those four, and "Hire a CA". Plans with AI add "Ask" before "Hire a CA", so the nav is 6 items, or 7 with Ask. Family is a workspace context, not a nav item.
Why
The CA marketplace is a top-level destination, not only an action from Tax. Ask is a pillar-level surface for AI plans only; hiding it for Free and Self avoids advertising a paywall.
Impact
apps/website/src/components/app/use-role-nav.ts—PERSONAL_NAV(6 items) plusASK_NAV_ITEMwhenhasAiPlan.- Admin and CA roles have their own nav lists.
- Pillar pages are unchanged: pillar-inbox, pillar-tax, pillar-expense, pillar-portfolio, pillar-dashboard.
- Marketplace values stay in marketplace-economics; see also four-pillars.
Status
Active. Replaces 2026-05-30-foundational-four-pillar-product-structure.
Sources
apps/website/src/components/app/use-role-nav.ts